This last week, however, as I sat alone at an Italian restaurant waiting for my shrimp and asparagus risotto, looking across the street at the pristine manicured lawn of the courthouse, I was heavily aware of why I had come to Easton. While little had changed – the place was more beautiful than ever – I wasn’t there to enjoy myself or to revel in romance. I was there to support my friend Kelly during the trial against the woman who shook her son Trevor.
Kelly reached out to me last January during our trial. She had read about Noah and about the trial in the Washington Post article. She wrote me the most candid and heart-wrenching email. Trevor and Noah were born the same day: November 29, 2008. They should have been friends. They should have shared a laugh about being twins or brothers. But what binds them is that they were each shaken. On September 2nd, at nine months old, Trevor was shaken.
How do I hear Kelly’s story and not think of my own? It isn’t possible. Kelly had been told that Trevor had choked on his vomit and had aspirated. I had been told that Noah had choked on his milk and had been taken to the emergency room. When I arrived I expected to see him in a crib with a nurse alongside him. I expected him to be tired but awake. What I saw was my son lying naked on a table, his body lifeless, and a team of doctors and nurses trying to help him breathe. When Kelly walked into her daycare provider’s house she expected to see Trevor choking. What Kelly saw instead was her daycare provider administering CPR, the 911 dispatcher giving her instructions over the phone. I heard the 911 call during the trial. All 8 minutes of it. Twice. I will never forget the sound of the door opening, of Kelly walking into the room where Trevor lie on the floor, the sound that she made – something like a scream and a cry. Primal. Her friends and family in the courtroom burst into tears. What else could you do? It was a sound that ripped through your soul. Trevor, Kelly testified, “looked dead” when she first saw him.
God, I know that pain. I know that moment. I knew in that instant I first saw Noah that death was close, hovering. But here is where Noah and Trevor’s stories split. They have alternate endings. Noah spent 18 days in the hospital, in and out of two comas, constant seizures, blindness. One baby gone, another baby born. But even on my darkest days, my loneliest hours, the moments when I wonder how much more heartache I can take, I still have Noah. I still have him. On September 2nd, hours after Kelly first saw Trevor lying on his daycare provider’s floor, she was told that he had a “0% chance of survival.” The next day, on September 3rd at 7:33 PM, Trevor was pronounced dead. As I write this my heart boomerangs in my chest and my throat tightens. Because I am heartbroken for Kelly. I am devastated that Trevor was taken from all of us who might have loved him had we been blessed enough to know him. I am sick that Kelly and her husband had to come home each day after that grueling trial to an empty house.
And I am angry!
I am angry that Gail Dobson lost her patience. I am angry that there are ignorant people out there who deny that a baby can die from being shaken. I am a part of a sad group of mommies. The group keeps growing as we reach out and find each other, sharing our stories, our frustrations, our children’s losses. Gail Dobson was found guilty last week of 2nd Degree Murder, 1st Degree Child Abuse and 2nd Degree Child Abuse. That is a victory. But just like when Trudy was found guilty, the joy is tempered with pain. Yes, justice – in the legal sense – has been served. But what changes in our daily lives? It certainly doesn’t give Noah any relief from his seizures. His vision isn’t going to magically improve. Trevor won’t ever sit in his highchair licking off the Gerber puffs that are stuck to his palms, two smart doggies hovering below him for their free snack. Because Trevor is gone. There will never be justice in that.
Please remember that for every person you share Noah’s story with – or Trevor’s – you are educating people on the danger of this horrendous form of child abuse. For every person you educate, you are quite possibly saving a life.







